by Teresa Genaro
Now is usually when they start. The comments about going to the Preakness, the inevitable warnings about the “bad” neighborhood, the perpetuation of the image of Baltimore as a lawless, terrifying abyss of crime.
This year those comments started a little earlier, the warnings a little more urgent, given the unrest in Baltimore following the death of Freddie Gray in police custody last month. On social media, racing fans wondered whether they should attend the Preakness this year, or whether the Preakness should be moved, or whether it should be held at all.
The city of Baltimore is graceful, historic, and beautiful. Much of it is also ravaged by poverty, and parts of it by crime, and the areas that abut Pimlico Race Course represent all of these Baltimore realities. Within walking distance across Northern Parkway is Mt. Washington, a middle- and upper-middle class neighborhood of tree-lined, undulating streets with the feel of an arboretum; “across the track,” in the local vernacular, one treads more cautiously, aware of gang presences. Closer to Pimlico live poor and middle-class families, mostly African-American.
Tony Pridgen has lived near the track for much of the last 40 years. A veteran and retired corrections officer who now works security for nearby Sinai Hospital, Pridgen grew up in the neighborhood known as Garrison, returning as an adult to care for his ailing grandfather.
I think I’m skipping the Preakness this year unless they move it to civilized Laurel.
— Brian Russell (@BRussellSoFla) April 27, 2015
There is no way they should have The Preakness in Baltimore. MOVE IT TO PARX!!!
— AZ (@AtoZ128) May 4, 2015
@Haflings @Junebug1952 @PimlicoRC Cancel The Preakness, lets see if Governor Hogan has the stones. BTW Pimlico Track in a crap neighborhood
— Mr. Wonderful (@JValentinesbro) April 27, 2015
Many tweets during and after the Baltimore riots called for the Preakness to be moved or canceled.
“This neighborhood is like a family,” he said by phone recently. “It was full of older people when I was small, and now it’s their kids having kids.”
There are some places, he acknowledged, that you don’t want to be at night, but that doesn’t mean that he accepts the universal characterization of his neighborhood as unsafe.
He’s used to the negative depictions of where he lives, particularly from people who don’t spend a lot of time there.
“I learned a long time ago,” he said. “When people don’t really know you or your neighborhood, you shrug it off.
“You don’t get defensive with it. As much as bad things go on, good things are happening, too.”
One of those good things, he said, is the Preakness.
“There’s a lot of excitement,” he said. “It’s great for the teenagers and the older kids. They can’t wait to get carts to help people carry their stuff to the track; they stock up on soda and water to sell.”
And as they do around Saratoga Race Course, local people advertise their yards for parking.
“It’s definitely a job opportunity,” said Pridgen.
Jessica Hammond, wife of trainer Scott Hammond, also works at Sinai, the hospital at which she was born, “overlooking the track” from birth, she said. A Maryland native—from one of the many parts of Baltimore County that bear no resemblance to their urban neighbors—she read the social media comments that cropped up over the last 10 days with irritation, particularly as many of her co-workers live in the area around Pimlico, and others, who lived further away, had to wonder about whether they’d be able to get home, or what they’d find when they did.
“…the concern right now,” she tweeted from their Somerset Racing account on the heaviest night of protests and violence, “[is] the safety of the people of Baltimore.”
“You don’t need to make a bad situation worse by panicking people,” she said. “It’s counter-productive. Be concerned about the people who live here, and if you’re not in a position to help because you’re far away, you can help people’s attitudes about what’s going on.”
Orioles’ executive vice president and chief operating officer John Angelos didn’t waste any time in making a statement about what was going on in his home city, taking to his seldom-used Twitter account with a strongly worded, multi-tweet declaration after the Orioles were asked, on Saturday, April 25, to keep fans inside Oriole Park at Camden Yards after a night game, as protestors swarmed the area.
“I agree,” wrote Angelos, “that the principle of peaceful, non-violent protest and the observance of the rule of law [are] of utmost importance in any society. MLK, Gandhi, Mandela, and all great opposition leaders throughout history have always preached this precept. Further, it is critical that in any democracy investigation must be completed and due process must be honored before any government or police members are judged responsible.”
He continued:
[su_quote]That said, my greater source of personal concern, outrage and sympathy beyond this particular case is focused neither upon one night’s property damage nor upon the acts [of one group] but is focused rather upon the past four-decade period during which an American political elite have shipped middle class and working class jobs away from Baltimore and cities and towns around the US to 3rd world dictatorships like China and others [and] plunged tens of millions of good hard working [A]mericans into economic devastation and then followed that action around the nation by diminishing every American’s civil rights protections in order to control an unfairly impoverished population living under an ever-declining standard of living and suffering at the butt end of an ever-more militarized and aggressive surveillance state.“The innocent working families of all backgrounds whose lives and dreams have been cut short by excessive violation, surveillance, and other abuses of the bill of rights by government pay the true price, an ultimate price, and one that far exceeds the importance of any kids’ game played tonight, or ever, at Camden Yards.
“We need to keep in mind people are suffering and dying around the US and while we are thankful no one was injured at Camden Yards, there is a far bigger picture for poor Americans in Baltimore and everywhere who don’t have jobs and are losing economic[,] civil and legal rights and this…makes inconvenience at a ball game irrelevant in light of the needless suffering government is inflicting upon ordinary Americans. [/su_quote]
Earlier this week, Angelos explained what spurred that response.
“What initially instigated my reaction was that enough is enough with this refrain about people needing to work harder, to pull themselves up by their own bootstraps,” he said.
“When it gets to the point,” continued Angelos, a fixture at the Saratoga racing meeting who co-produces with Andy Serling the weekly “At The Post” radio show from downtown Saratoga, “that you’re talking about social conditions through the one-dimensional lens of how it impacts what are basically entertaining but unimportant sporting events in the grand scheme of things, that reflects how society has gotten lost along the way.”
Angelos grew up in Baltimore and has watched what has happened as the city’s manufacturing base has been sent overseas, eliminating thousands of working class jobs.
“Bethlehem Steel, the shipyard, Western Electric, Unilever, General Motors,” he said, listing the companies that have left Baltimore. “When those jobs disappear, when they go offshore, you can’t deny the impact that had on neighborhoods like the North/Penn area [which withstood significant damage from looting] and Pimlico.”
Moving the Preakness, he said, would just make the situation worse.
“How much more can you ignore these areas?” he asked. “If you follow logic—move the Preakness because the area is distressed — wouldn’t you just be furthering the ignoring of these areas? Why would you do that?
“To the extent that that area has degenerated over the last 35 years or so, the question isn’t, ‘Should we move the Preakness?’ The question is, ‘Why has this happened?’”
The racing analyst at Pimlico and Laurel Park, Gabby Gaudet was, like Jessica Hammond, disturbed at the portrayal of the city in which she works.
“The media didn’t show the non-violent protests,” she said. “They made it look like everyone was lighting cars on fire.”
Gaudet recently led a Pimlico service mission, working with jockeys, trainers, backstretch workers, and racing executives on a Habitat for Humanity project. Building houses alongside people putting in their own “sweat equity” as a down payment on a rebuilt property, she and her team, which included jockeys Trevor McCarthy, Victor Carrasco, Forest Boyce and Sheldon Russell, and Maryland Jockey Club executive Georganne Hale, and David Richardson from the local horsemen’s group, raised nearly $5,000 for the organization in addition to their physical participation in the project.
“It was so impressive,” she said. “Habitat for Humanity buys a whole block of housing, to transform not just a building or two, but a whole community.”
The travails of Baltimore’s residents are not limited to those living in neighborhoods in the midst or in need of revitalization. Tony Pridgen can relate all too well to the experience of people of color in Baltimore and nationwide, to people who aren’t fortunate enough to have his background or connections.
“I recently got stopped,” he said, “by an officer who told me that I ran three red lights.
“I said, ‘Three red lights? I haven’t run three red lights in 40 years.’
“’Are you calling me a liar?’ the officer, who was white, asked me,” recounted Pridgen. “Then he called me a black piece of s—t.”
Pridgen will be at the Preakness this year, as he has been for many years. He went first when he was five years old, taken by his grandmother.
“I love it,” he said. “I like horse racing.”
And while he concedes that there are areas that Preakness visitors might want to avoid, he has another message for the people who will throng his neighborhood in a little more than a week.
“The first thing people think of when they think about Baltimore,” he said, “is The Wire and The Corner,” referring to two HBO series that focused on the crime and poverty in the city.
“It’s more than that,” he said. “Don’t label us as ‘the riot people.’”
Unless there is another round of civil unrest (which I have no reason to believe that there will be within the next 9 days) the 140th running of the Preakness should definitely be held at Old Hilltop. However, that having been said….. pimlico
Should the Stronach Group be forced to decide to shutter one of the two Maryland tracks, I think Pimlico should be the one to get the ax. This is not simply an issue about the surrounding area, though I would factor that in . It has to do with the quality of the barn area and room for expansion. In the interest of full disclosure, I’ve never worked in Maryland (my career has been in Southern Cal and Kentucky) but I’ve spoken to enough horseman who feel that Laurel is the preferred facility for training and racing. One of the biggest factors is the more rural setting of Laurel. Non horse people don’t understand how valuable it is to let a horse graze in the morning. Or how the barn environment can be beneficial both physically and psychologically to an equine athletes AND their accompanying human caretakers.
Is tradition a great thing? Of course it is, and it should be preserved whenever feasible. But Pimlico has probably passed its prime and economic realities might indicate that it’s time for its swan song.
Appreciate that perspective, Jeff. As much as it would pain my historical heart to see Pimlico go, what you say makes sense, and I’d leave that decision to people who are more involved in Maryland racing.
Here, I wanted to show another side of the conversation about Baltimore and the area around Pimlico…and hope to do more of it next week when I’m there.
Thanks for this story Teresa.
Last year when we did the Retired Racehorse Project’s Thoroughbred Makeover at Pimlico we put tent stabling in a parking lot where neighbors regularly pass through. It was fenced, but getting through was easy. We hired a security guard at night.
Well not a soul bothered the horses or the competitors that weekend, but they did stop in to check out the scene. The highlight for one of our competitors was giving impromptu pony rides to local kids on his Thoroughbred. We got an email from a local mother asking if her teenage son could volunteer in the stables. An out-of-town visitor got lost with her horse trailer in the neighborhood. She asked on older woman standing on a corner how to get to Pimlico. She not only got directions, but the woman said, “Is it true that they are doing a show there this weekend and that Chris McCarron will be there?”
Yes, it is a real neighborhood with real people just like you and me. The schools aren’t good, the jobs are scarce, housing is falling apart, and young people are frustrated. Some of the really smart kids get lucky breaks and find a way into jobs that pay well, but when they do they usually leave the neighborhood. But guess what. They also think the horses are magnificent. We have something in common.
Speaking of kids,local school,Arlington Elementary over 100 kids over during Preakness week for a tour and a talk with a jockey. They also get to pet the tack ponies and have their picture taken by the track photographer. Having Pimlico is a very definite plus for them!
I worked at Churchill and it’s in a very working class section of Louisville. But the backside area has grass and there’s lots of room and the barns are pretty nice. Hollywood Park wasn’t in the most desirable area of L.A. either (Inglewood).
But this stuff goes beyond tracks being located in poverty-stricken zip codes. It speaks to a bigger issue of there simply being too much racing in America, given what the market will bear. Track attendance is down and the advent of racinos hasn’t been the magic bullet that many thought it would be.
I wish American racing was more like Europe, in that there’s less of it but the product that is delivered is of a higher quality. In England, Ireland and France it still is the Sport of Kings. They don’t have any Delaware Parks and Charles Towns. But that’s a different diatribe for a different time!
Pimlico is in a dreadful and dangerous area of Baltimore. There is no way to put lipstick on a pig. Should the Stronach group decide to keep only one track, Laurel is the one to keep open. It not also gives maximum accessibility to not only Baltimore fans, but also DC-area fans. And at this point in time, DC has the wealthier, more potentially horse-friendly patrons than does the Baltimore ghetto.
Ha! Virginia Horseman, that’s EXACTLY what I said about Baltimore in a post on Google+ and Twitter earlier this week.
https://plus.google.com/115149788057335102806/posts/hKqcNRLJLer
I’ve often thought that a refurbished Pimlico could become one of America’s great urban parks. With its tradition, location and potential for job creation it could be part of the solution in western Baltimore. Surely, it would need city, state and federal investment (money) to make it work but the solution lies with with the track owner and the neighborhood working together. One side or the other can’t make it work alone.
Funny–or perhaps not–that the thread has been taken over by people promoting their own interests, offering the exact reductive, limited views of Baltimore that the post debunks, views that show little regard for lives and neighborhoods.
Teresa, for years I have admired your work from afar. This may be your best piece ever. I try to keep an open mind, and your brilliant essay forced me to see the bigger picture and modify my reaction to the Baltimore protests/rioting. If one watches a certain network that must have shown that crazily driven car race again and again through that street fire, one enters a perverted view of reality. Your article presents a saner and more balanced view, not one that panders to the darker angels of our nature in order to capture higher ratings and income. I hope your students appreciate how lucky they are to have you as a teacher/administrator.
Thank you, William, for those very kind words, especially about this article. I appreciate them more than I can say.
I went to the Preakness in 2009. I was mesmerized by the track and its history. I was thrilled to speak to Chip Woolly and Gary Stevens and other trainers. It’s a treat to be able to see the horses in the morning and get a tour of the Preakness barns. People are just people. If you go with a positive attitude and don’t think about the poverty or whatever else bothers you, people will treat you great! I liked seeing the locals on the streets renting their driveways for parking and serving beverages to fans as we passed. I was in awe to cross the track on the backside where Seabiscuit and War Admiral had the famous match race of 1938 with Seabiscuit winning by 4 lengths.
I saw Zenyatta at Hollywood Park many times. I loved that track. The area was interesting, but when you are at the races, you are at the races. I loved Bay Meadows too! Those two tracks are my favorites. I have been to the Belmont Stakes in 2012, and 2014 and found the people all over NYC to be so kind and helpful. I remember walking from my hotel in Queens to the track and enjoying people watching.
You have to use caution at night in all cities. If flights were not so much, I would jump on a plane and head to the Preakness. If anyone wants to help me get there, I would generously appreciate that. The Preakness, must stay at the Preakness or Pimlico. The triple crown would never be the same if it’s moved to another track.
So for all you track neighborhood and people bashers open your hearts and goodness will follow!
Teresa, everywhere on line where people can post their comments is exactly as you described it, the furthering of self interest. No matter what the subject, the same people keep writing the same things over and over again, whether it is germane or not.
Just wanted to stop in and say thanks, everyone, for taking the time to comment on this article. Clearly a nerve’s been touched here, and a debate fostered, which is a good thing.
Did someone really suggest moving the Preakness to Parx? Really?
On the other hand, I believe we have just found 1 of the 7 people in the world that actually thinks Parx is great.
This article is the best thing I’ve read or seen to explain exactly what is happening in Baltimore and why. It reminded me of what Lester Holt said on the NBC Evening News. He said that people kept coming up to him on the sidewalks of Baltimore, and asking him, “Where were you all BEFORE the riots?” I’ll never forget that, because it illustrates the REAL problem. When there’s no noise to get our attention, many are content to ignore the injustices around us. The problems of Baltimore have been there a long time, and will continue indefinitely, if something isn’t done by somebody, or many somebodies, to change things there. The answer is not to close Pimlico. The answer is to fix up the neighborhood that surrounds it. If some of the affluent people in this country were to stop being so selfish, and be willing to share their abundance, we could begin to put an end to the poverty that cripples neighborhoods. To tear down Pimlico would be like what has happened too often in my hometown of Louisville, where historic buildings have been demolished and replaced by parking lots. What’s the point in that?
Great article. Think it should be considered for Eclipse Award next year. Haven’t seen any other racing media cover this story with as much depth as what is here, and racing fans clearly care about it.
Teresa, great article! Mr. Angelos, you are my hero. You have summarized the issues perfectly. The media should be ashamed of it’s inaccurate depiction of Baltimore City because of few law brakers. I am a proud Baltimore native and have been attending the Preakness since the mid 50s. Although I now live in Tennessee, I still travel to Baltimore for the Preakness. Move this great horse race away from this great city …… I say NEVER.
Thank you for this article. The story in Baltimore is much more complex than the TV news shows and you shared some of that depth in this article. Abandoning Pimlico would be a shame, though I realize the economics of the industry may not allow for it to stay open forever. This year, though, let’s celebrate Pimlico, the Preakness, and the people of Baltimore.
Maryland does not need 2 tracks. Bowie is gone and pimlico should be shuttered. The scene is changing. The only time tracks get patrons under 30 is on event days or with free concerts. They come to drink and drink.
NOT to gamble. Too many tracks on the east coast. Too many cheap claimers. Build low rent affordable housing or a park for the kids but shut pimlico down. It’s a graveyard.
Yeh, that’s JUST what we need–EVEN MORE ‘LOW RENT’ housing- at TAXPAYER expense to further exacerbate the ghetto problem! GET REAL! The damned govt needs to stop making it hard for businesses to do BUSINESS and create INCENTIVES FOR BUSINESSES to thrive instead of allowing our cities to fall into despair catering to low-lifes. If I had a horse in the race, I wouldn’t go near Baltimore–that place is a cess pool on a GOOD day! Esp. not after the turmoil of late. Damned shame that ALL of our once-great cities are nothing more than Welfare states now and unfit for decent folks OR the “sport of kings. Those heathens want to act like that–good–wall them in–lock them in and leave them to their own devices! I would rather see the Preakness moved to Charles Town than go to Baltimore again! Sat with Big Brown’s owners in 2008 but the surrounding area gave me the heebie jeebies! VERY RUN DOWN. Did NOT feel safe walking anywhere near the track. Thankfully, we parked in a private lot–albeit for 75.00!! FING CRAZY!!
I’ve attended the preakness for 15 years straight often with my teenage children. I’ve never had a problem. The people in the neighborhoods that surround Pimlico are friendly and appreciate the economic activity that the race brings.
The track is a dump however , but I kind of like thinking that it looked the same way back when War Admiral ran with Seabiscuit…
I’m going again this year and bringing 20 people with me. I don’t expect there will be a problem.
Been going since 1997, and will be there again this year, although if the Preakness was a couple of weeks ago, I really would have had to rethink the trip, as I’m sure a lot of people would have. And I don’t think it would have been unreasonable to do so.
As for the companies that left Baltimore, they went with horse-like instincts and decided that flight was the best option when they were threatened by an encroaching government. It’s not the companies’ fault that government over-regulation and over-taxation forced them to go elsewhere to stay in business. Every city that goes with progressive policies usually ends up like Cleveland, Detroit, Chicago, and, sadly, Baltimore. Companies owe it to their stakeholders to stay financially viable to fight another day, even if it means picking up and leaving someplace that I’m sure they would’ve rather stayed, had the host city and state created an economically fostering environment for their business to thrive. Too bad the neighborhoods surrounding these employers must pay that price. I believe this idea is what Mr. Angelos was referring to.
Jared G …….. Respectfully, you might want to re-read Mr. Angelos’ comments.
With respect to some of the comments here, I am in business to race horses. I have zero interest in being used as a pawn by politicians and journalists to be the agent for revitalization of a ghetto.
I race regularly in the Maryland circuit; partners and potential partners have reported repeated instances of trepidation and problems associated with going to Pimlico to attend workouts or races., such as squeege men accosting them at traffic lights and having a car broken into in the parking lot while inside the track.
We have never had any similar problems – ever – in Laurel.
I grew up in nearby Silver Spring. Pimlico and nearby Baltimore were my mecca. Years ago, I swore that I would move to Baltimore, my dream city! The business director and camp mother lived across the street from the track; you can see their house when the camera pans on the horses as they are about to enter the stretch. When I went shopping wearing my Preakness regalia on Friday in the large Seven Mile Market, people stopped me, embracing the Preakness and the horse legacy of Baltimore, -unlike the Belmont Stakes near where I now live. “Up the street” literally, ies Sagamore Farm where modern racing’s strong roots hail from Native Dancer and the horsy Glyndon Vallley. OK, my memories were back in the day but I prefer to think of Baltimore as the home of immigrants and Avalon.